“Boy, would you like another baby?”
Our family of four was snuggled in his bed.
We had read our books and said our prayers.
We were laying in the dark, enjoying our last few minutes together.
Lullabies and a white noise machine mingled across the room.
These are the times when we talk about our adventures of the day or our upcoming plans.
Or weighty issues.
Like asking an almost-three year-old if we should have another baby.
We aren’t, by the way, having another baby.
But we are always looking to gauge his reaction to this baby.
And, I suppose, to see whether he might be interested in another.
At some point down the road.
But not now.
“Yes,” he answered. “I want another baby.”
I breathed.
Gratitude and relief flowed.
He was still happy with our new addition.
Every day is easier.
Every day, happier.
Every day, we find a better rhythm.
Finally, the sun in my life is shining again.
“I want a new baby and our Baby to share her little tiny crib. Can they share that crib?”
He held his hands up to show us how small the crib seems to him, a big boy.
A big boy who asks, not infrequently, to exchange his full bed for his “little” toddler bed.
He continued. “I have a baby in my tummy. It’s getting ready to come out.”
He flexed his stomach muscles to mimic the movements of a full term baby.
Beneath his footed flannel pajamas, his stomach undulated.
It was a surprisingly accurate impression.
And then, suddenly, he stopped.
Something had occurred to him.
“But—can I have a pink baby?”
A pink baby?
That request surprised me.
I mean, to be honest, the one we have is pretty pink.
Her skin is pink. Her clothes are pink. Her pacifiers are pink.
I don’t know how much more pink you can get.
At least without dyeing a baby’s hair.
Which isn’t really my scene.
“Or maybe just another pink easter egg cookie,” he said, referencing a cookie he’d eaten a month ago.
Apparently it was a memorable cookie.
Perhaps more memorable than acquiring a sibling.
I fought my laughter.
And found my voice. “So do you want a pink baby or a pink cookie?”
He thought for a second before pronouncing his verdict.
“A cookie. I want a pink cookie.”
A cookie it is.









That’s a smart kid. As much as I love my babies I would want a cookie instead of another baby.
Jess recently posted..Let There Be Growth
I do think he’s on to something.
Aw, that’s just incredibly sweet!!!
I hope I can have similarly cute conversations with my toddler when the time comes

Alison@Mama Wants This recently posted..Neither Here Nor There
You will. And I look forward to hearing about them.
My son is convinced that you can buy babies at the baby store. He’s been begging for a new baby brother for weeks.
The Mommy Psychologist recently posted..Online Bullying and Teenage Suicide
Mine used to think I could get him one at the Post Office. Apparently that’s where all interesting packages come from….
I love how much he loves her even if he picked a cookie over another sibling.
JDaniel4′s Mom recently posted..Examining His Learning Choices
Thank you! He does love her–it’s been wonderful to watch.
The night before we flew to pick up our youngest, i asked my only if she was sure about wanting a sibling (we had not told her why we were flying to TX) She said, oh yes, Mummy, and i will share everything.’
Just as i went to turn out the light – she said, and Mummy, i want a black one …
By Word of Mouth Musings recently posted..Wordy Wordless Wednesday – Be Yourself
That’s a wonderful story, Nicole. I love the things that children say, how honest and heartfelt they are.
Of course, the flip side, is that my son actually wants me to have a PINK baby. And I’m just going to have to disappoint him on that one.
Pink Easter egg cookies are delicious, no doubt.
But oh. That pink baby.
Oh my.
Thank you. She is pretty awesome, even if I’m a bit biased….
Haha too funny. I love your writing… you have a such a great writing voice!
Mindi recently posted..Mommy Moments Photography Challenge: Here We Go!
Thank you–glad you liked it!
Oh that is soooo sweet!
I love that he kind of gets it but not really.
So wonderful this place he’s in.
Leighann recently posted..Say Yes to Meeting A Celeb!
Thanks, Leighann! I think he really wants a PINK baby. Not sure I can deliver on that one….
That must have been some cookie! Here’s a comparable exchange from when S was three:
GIRL: I like you, Mommy.
ME: Oh, thank you. I like you, too, S.
GIRL: I like J [little brother], too.
ME: That’s good. What about Daddy?
GIRL: I like Daddy a little bit.
ME: Only a little bit?
GIRL (quickly): I like Daddy very much.
DAD: Do you like me more or do you like banana bread more?
GIRL (with zest): Banana bread!
DAD: That’s what I thought.
GIRL: I like you, J, myself, and banana bread!